Adam’s Blog: What do we mean by a “good school”?
In recent times my blogs have tended to be updates on our work as opposed to addressing issues directly. This week though I really wanted to write something about “good schools”, in response to the publication of this year’s League Tables in the most recent edition of the Sunday Independent.
The League Tables, released annually by a number of publications, cite the percentage of students in each Secondary School in the country, in a given year, who go on to study in Third Level education after completing their Leaving Certificate examinations.
The term “League Tables” of course implies a premier-league type scenario – those sending the most students to third level are in for Champions League glory, while those who send the least are in the dreaded relegation zone and not taken too seriously. Those in the middle are seen as bog standard. But is that really how we should be assessing the quality of our schools?
Now don’t get me wrong – of course exam results matter and of course the ability of schools to assist their students in selecting, pursuing and obtaining a course and career path is one important element of any “good school”. It is one that is worthy of recognition but it is just one element. If you see it as the definition of a “good school” then, by extension, you believe the purpose of a school is not really to educate someone but rather to simply act as a cram factory for the Leaving Certificate.
Malcolm Forbes said that “the purpose of an education is to replace an empty mind with an open mind”, in other words education is not just about filling a brain with facts, rather it is about exposing people to the world, encouraging creativity and curiosity and exposing people to different ways of thinking, doing and living. It enables a person to reach their own personal potential, whatever that might be
Therefore is a school’s openness to diversity not just as relevant a measure in how we rate “good schools”? Is a school’s approach to extra-curricular activities and experiences not just as relevant? Is a school’s attitude in terms of challenging people’s perceptions and encouraging different learning styles not just as integral a measure of a “good school”?
I passionately believe it is and I believe when we are honest and see education in this fuller, purer sense then we also, by extension, create better, more inclusive schools for people with Autism and other disabilities.
I am not just writing this blog for the sake of having a moan – our current attitudes towards league tables, I believe, are impacting on the lives of people with Autism in the education system, both directly and indirectly.
Directly, we are seeing people with Autism face soft barriers to entry as a result of this strange, dated and yet ever more popular means of measuring schools. Naturally, school principals and boards of management are concerned with the reputation of their school and, sadly, the public’s measure of reputation is centred around these league tables. Therefore, principals and boards of management respond to this demand from the public and this is where people with Autism begin to suffer.
Many principals deciding on whether to offer a place to a student with Autism will, perhaps subconsciously, have league tables and public perception on their mind. If he/she takes in too many students with disabilities, who may not be appropriately served by our existing examination system, how will this impact on league tables? If this school becomes the accommodating, inclusive school for people with Autism and other disabilities, how will the community respond? Will people begin to see this school as simply a school for those who cannot or may be perceived to be unable to perform in the examinations system?
This thought process regularly influences schools and in AsIAm we have met so many families who have experienced soft barriers to entry as a result, with comments like “oh perhaps the school down the road could better meet his needs”, “we just don’t have a place to offer her”, “the students support needs are just too great” all too regular responses to applications for a school place for someone with Autism.
Meanwhile many schools do not embrace this attitude and open their doors (for a time at least) – yet receive no kudos and in the process our so called “mainstreaming” policy proves not be universal but subject to the creation of barriers or the goodwill of school administrations.
Any system of ranking schools which encourages this thought process among the general public and which influences schools in turn to have these concerns, cannot be good news for our community or for wider Irish society.
Should we not be more concerned with whether a school is able to meet the diverse needs of students? Is a “good school” not one where those who are highly academic and able to manage in our examinations system get lots of support and encouragement and their place in college, while a student who may be less academic or who may not be able to conform to the rigidity of the exams system would be able to reach their own potential and access the next step in their life, in a manner suitable to them.
Indirectly, there is a much wider societal impact to this outlook on education. It in turn equates “Leaving Cert” and “Success” and so, by extension, often influences our attitude towards people with Autism or other disabilities whose success may look different, whose aspirations may be very different but who in turn still obtain their potential, develop their talents and are happy – the true definition of success.
So to conclude, I want to say I am sure many of the schools who ranked very highly in the League Tables also provide very rounded experiences for their students and support inclusion. Equally, though I am sure many who ranked lower, using this system, provide a great experience for students based on personal potential, ability and need. In both cases I am sure the reverse is also true.
I don’t blame newspapers for publishing the league tables in the manner that they do – they are simply providing the information which the public currently values. This is about out values as a society – education, and how we assess its value, plays a huge role in our wider social fabric and if we do not believe in a diverse, inclusive education system then we do not believe in a diverse, inclusive society.
I hope in time we can think of a new way to measure our schools – which includes progression rates but also looks at a much bigger, bolder picture – now that would be a league table I would take very seriously! That would be a league table which would actually be of use to all families, including those affected by Autism and other disabilities.
Featured image courtesy of winnond / FreeDigitalPhotos.net
by AsIAm.ie - 26 January, 2016
Last updated by AsIAm.ie - January 26, 2016
Minister for Education Reminds Schools of Obligations to Students with SEN Following Enough Is Enough Protest
by Eleanor Walsh - 1 May, 2019
Yesterday Minister for Education Joe McHugh TD published a statement reminding schools and patron...[...]
AsIAm to Join Enough Is Enough Protest on Lack of School Places for Autistic Students at Leinster House
by AsIAm.ie - 25 April, 2019
In light of the recent publication of our Invisible Children report on School Absence and Withdra...[...]
Explainer: What Happened in Senator Devine’s Commencement Matter on SEN Schools Provision in the Seanad?
by AsIAm.ie - 12 April, 2019
On Thursday morning, Senator Máire Devine submitted a Commencement Matter to Seanad Éireann on th...[...]
Explainer: What Happened in Senator Ó Ríordáin’s Commencement Matter on School Places in the Seanad?
by Eleanor Walsh - 10 April, 2019
On Tuesday afternoon, Senator Aodhán Ó Ríordáin submitted a Commencement Matter to Seanad Éireann...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 29 March, 2019
Calling all schools, teachers, and educators! April is World Autism Month, and we have developed ...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 21 February, 2019
On Monday evening we held our Community Support event in Co. Limerick on Autism and Play. We ...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 30 January, 2019
As the national autistic advocacy organisation, AsIAm receives a huge volume of messages from fam...[...]
“It’s Not A Disorder”: Minister Joe McHugh Challenges Himself and TDs on Inclusive Language around Autism
by AsIAm.ie - 23 January, 2019
Following constructive and insightful discussions and correspondence with AsIAm in recent week...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 24 October, 2018
Our survey on special schools and classes is now live and open to the public! If you're a school ...[...]
by Emer Ring - 28 September, 2018
All autistic children experience challenges in communication. While many might have an extensive ...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 21 September, 2018
AsIAm would like to thank Dr Emer Ring and her colleagues from Mary Immaculate College (MIC)'s De...[...]
by Emer Ring - 20 September, 2018
The National Council for Special Education (NCSE) has just completed a review of the Special Need...[...]
by Emer Ring - 20 September, 2018
Research continues to tell us that we must view ‘challenging behaviour’ as a way in which the chi...[...]
by Emer Ring - 19 September, 2018
Your child’s teacher may already be aware of autistic children's sensory needs. However, if your ...[...]
by Emer Ring - 18 September, 2018
An Individual Education Plan, often referred to as an ‘IEP’, is a plan to support your child’s le...[...]
by Emer Ring - 14 September, 2018
If your child doesn’t want to go back to school, it's important to talk about the reasons why the...[...]
by Emer Ring - 11 September, 2018
We all struggle getting back into our regular routine after holidays and for autistic children, w...[...]
by Emer Ring - 7 September, 2018
There is a wide range of resources available to support parents and children on this exciting jou...[...]
by Emer Ring - 4 September, 2018
It is a really good idea and absolutely essential to arrange a meeting with your child’s teacher,...[...]
by Emer Ring - 31 August, 2018
Parents and families are preparing their children for school from the day they are born and not j...[...]
by Emer Ring - 29 August, 2018
Starting school is one of the biggest events in both a family member's and a child's life. All be...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 31 May, 2018
This week, the National Council for Special Education (NCSE) launched its review into the Special...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 17 October, 2017
Laura Crean is a member of AsIAm's Youth Leadership Team and currently in her first year of study...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 2 October, 2017
Louise Ryan from Co. Limerick, a mother of two young boys on the autistic spectrum, talks about h...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 22 September, 2017
It’s the time of month again to go back to school and starting third level education, even going ...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 13 September, 2017
In this week’s blog, Amy Tracey, a second year business studies student at NCI, talks about her j...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 29 October, 2015
The last few weeks have been insanely busy for us in AsIAm.ie, with the "Back to School" period s...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 6 July, 2015
If you ever have the opportunity to discuss Autism with a young child I highly recommend it. I ha...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 15 June, 2015
Hey everyone, It's been a couple of weeks since I've written a blog, but we have made exciting p...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 24 January, 2015
I am sitting here preparing for "The Saturday Night Show", which I will be appearing on this even...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 15 September, 2014
Do you have a condition on the Autism Spectrum? Have you a son/daughter with the condition? Are y...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 10 September, 2014
The challenges of "Back to School" for students with Autism, and the launch of the AsIAm.ie "Back...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 26 August, 2014
Back to School means back to an endless number of phone calls, letters and meetings, for many par...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 25 August, 2014
Since our successful "Back to School" Handbooks launch last week, we have been delighted with the...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 25 August, 2014
Many families affected by Autism may be considering possible suitable extra-curricular activities...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 24 August, 2014
There is an old adage: "If you know one person with Autism, you know one person with Autism" It ...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 23 August, 2014
We are delighted with the response we have received from our recent media launch of our "Back to ...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 22 August, 2014
Yesterday we were delighted to launch our AsIAm "Back to School" Handbooks for teachers, parents...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 21 August, 2014
AsIAm.ie has today published a series of guides to help people with autism deal with the major ch...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 20 August, 2014
Tomorrow, AsIAm will launch its "Back to School" Handbooks on Autism, for parents, students and t...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 27 June, 2014
I haven't had the opportunity to write my own blog on the site for a few weeks as we have been bu...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 15 April, 2014
Primary school teacher Claire Heylin taught in the Asperger’s unit in St Joseph’s CBS, Fairview, ...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 2 April, 2014
My blog for World Autism Awareness Day - By Adam Harris Normal is a strange word we use to defin...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 20 January, 2014
A number of days ago I visited IADT in Dun Laoghaire to speak to "Psyc Soc" the college's society...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 19 February, 2013
"People don't understand me". This is the response you will get from many people, of all ages, wi...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 17 February, 2013
Well, it was good while it lasted, but tomorrow the morning tutorial bells will ring again and sc...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 2 February, 2013
I wanted to write this blog today in response to the fascinating content we have seen over the co...[...]
by AsIAm.ie - 28 January, 2013
The transition to Secondary School is a challenge for many people with Aspergers Syndrome, and ca...[...]