New #ChildrensFuturesIRL campaign focuses on children’s right to an adequate education
Leading children’s charities – including AsIAm, Barnardos, Children’s Rights Alliance, Inclusion Ireland, and National Parents Council Primary – are joining forces today to launch a major campaign called Children’s Futures, publishing a legal opinion and results from a brand-new parents’ survey.
While tentatively welcoming the Government’s announcement of a phased return for all schools on 1 March, campaign members are urging Government, education partners and others to come together and secure a cross-party, cross-sector public commitment to prioritise reopening – and keeping open – schools, in line with public health advice, and limiting the negative impact of lockdown on a generation of children.
This follows a legal opinion obtained by the Children’s Rights Alliance, which has found the blanket closure of schools, even with the provision of online learning, to be in breach of the right to an education, as guaranteed by the Constitution of Ireland, the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) and the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC). The decision to close schools and the continued lack of education for some groups of children is unconstitutional.
Tanya Ward of the Children’s Rights Alliance says: “While the Government may make decisions in the context of a public health emergency, it hasn’t provided an express legal basis for this intrusion on children’s fundamental right to education. After all, Government has a constitutional duty to ‘provide for free primary education’. But it has become quite apparent that there are categories of children for whom no educational provision is currently being made, and falls short of the State’s obligations.”
The legal opinion makes clear that online lessons do not translate into an adequate education for all children, owing to the fact that some children have additional educational needs and not all have sufficient IT facilities, broadband, adult supervision, nor environments where home-schooling is possible, owing to other hardships.
This is backed up by a recent National Parents Council Primary nationwide survey of over 6,000 parents, between 9 and 11 February, which demonstrates the difficulties of remote learning for children, with:
- only 37% of children having access to their own device, or 26% sharing with one or more people;
- 37% of children having unreliable broadband access;
- 46% of children either having limited access to quiet space or none at all; and
- 55% of children unable to access remote learning without adult supervision.
Responding to the survey results above, Áine Lynch of the National Parents Council Primary said: “Our survey results relating to remote learning demonstrate very clearly why 90% of parents now think schools should reopen in line with public health advice. In less than a month, our children will have endured a year’s worth of disruption to their schooling. It’s time we came together to fix this. We’ve heard much about the impact of Covid-19 on adults’ lives – and quite rightly so – but our children’s futures matter too. Where is plan B?”
Lorraine Dempsey of Inclusion Ireland said: “The negative impact of school closures on children with special educational needs (SEN) and disabilities is undeniable and for those children requiring the most intensive educational supports, the phased return to special school has been compounded by the unsettling plan to have a maximum of 50% of children attending special schools on alternating days. This needs to be resolved immediately by all parties involved and the focus moved onto providing an effective solution for children with SEN and disabilities in mainstream schools.”
Suzanne Connolly of Barnardos says: “For many of the children that we work with, the ongoing school closures are deeply worrying. Not only have they regressed in terms of educational attainment, but for many of these children school is a safe haven away from difficult, and sometimes threatening, home environments. They will not just bounce back from this. We need to have a strong and well-resourced recovery plan in place to support children’s social, emotional and educational needs.”
|The #ChildrensFutures campaign is calling on Government and education partners to work together to protect our children’s futures, recommending five urgent actions.
The Children’s Rights Alliance is organising a session with Alan D.P Brady BL and James Rooney BL that will outline the legal opinion on Friday 19 February at 1pm. They will be examining children’s right to an adequate education from a constitutional and human rights perspective, specifically in relation to the closure of schools in response to the Covid-19 pandemic. Details of the event can be found at www.childrensrights.ie or you can register using this eventbrite link.